The Dark Side of Tel Aviv

The glitzy celebrations for the White City's 'centenary' airbrush over a complex history of colonialism

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2009/oct/13/tel-aviv-origins-centenary

Abe Hayeem

Tuesday 13 October 2009 15.00 BST

The centenary of Tel Aviv, a city said to date from 1909, has provided a useful opportunity to present the face of Israel as a hip country built by Jewish pioneers on empty sands. Its vibrant cosmopolitan flavour, its commercial centre, its Mediterranean beaches, its liberal society and culture, are seen as signifying a truly commendable Zionist enterprise. According to the blurb on the centenary celebrations "several dozen families gathered on the sand dunes on the beach outside Yafo to allocate plots of land for a new neighbourhood they called Ahuzat Bayit, later known as Tel Aviv".

After the horrors of the Gaza onslaught and unending blockade, and the evidence of war crimes committed by the Israeli Defence Forces (IDF) early this year (which Israel has responded to with hysterical denial) no effort has been spared by the Israeli embassy and its propaganda machines to deflect the attention of the world to Israel's marvellous technical and medical discoveries, and to use Tel Aviv to present its upbeat image. Hence Tel Aviv festivities were organised in New York, Vienna, Copenhagen and Paris, with the creation of Tel Aviv beaches in Central Park and along the banks of the Seine, the Danube and Copenhagen's canals.

In London this week, the Israeli embassy teams up with easyJet to promote its new flights to Tel Aviv with a series of events around London to provide "a sweet taste of Israel's 24-hour city" as a "celebration of Israeli culture, which includes the valuable contribution from many minorities in Israel, such as Christians, Muslims and Druze".

While there is much on the surface that makes Tel Aviv enticing, this picture must be not be allowed to mask the dark underlying history of ethnic cleansing and land expropriation on which Tel Aviv was built, and that still continues today, even in Jaffa, while savouring the Israeli food and the Bauhaus architecture. In fact, the whole myth of Tel Aviv being built on empty sand dunes has been taken apart by various Israeli scholars, but none of this will feature in the promotional events.

Tel Aviv - the White City 1938

As Yonathan Mendel says in his article "Fantasising Israel" in the London Review of books:

It [Tel Aviv] didn't just emerge from the sand in 1909, as the Zionist myth tells us. Al-Sumayil, Salame, Sheikh Munis, Abu Kabir, Al-Manshiyeh: these are the names of some of the villages that made room for it and the names are still used today. Tel Avivians still talk about the Abu Kabir neighbourhood, they still meet on Salame Street. Tel Aviv University Faculty Club used to be the house of the sheikh of Sheikh Munis.

The Israeli organisation Zochrot has published maps of Tel Aviv showing where Arab localities existed, particularly in Jaffa and its suburbs to the south, and in smaller villages east and north of the city, but which have been erased from maps of the region and its posted signs.

Initially Tel Aviv in its infancy was an adjunct of Jaffa, which Mendel says:

was probably the most prosperous and cosmopolitan of all Palestinian cities, with a port, an industry (Jaffa oranges), an international school system and a lively cultural life. In 1949, after Jaffa had been almost completely emptied of its Palestinian inhabitants (only 4,000 were left out of a population of 70,000), the Israeli government decided to unite the two cities in one metropolis, to be called 'Tel Aviv-Jaffa'. In doing this, Ben-Gurion not only created a new Tel Aviv that was 'part of' biblical Jaffa, he erased the Palestinian city.

Jaffa - 1960

The city was subject to intensive shelling in 1948, when more than 60,000 of its residents were forced to leave – mostly fleeing to Gaza. Seventy-five per cent of the city was bulldozed, leaving only 4,000 Palestinians in the now run-down Ajame and Jabaliah neighbourhoods, which in fact today are the subject of intended clearance by the Amidar corporation, who have imposed fines on the residents for "illegally" improving their houses when they had refused to allow them to upgrade

What will be built in their place is luxurious real estate at fantastic prices beyond the reach of the existing inhabitants. Jaffa today has been turned into a picturesque artists' colony, in the houses expropriated from their Palestinian owners.

Distant from the portrayal of Tel Aviv as a beautiful cultural city is its significance as the centre for the Israeli military and military research in an area called HaKirya, where the IDF has had its headquarters since it was founded in 1948. In addition to occupying large areas in the heart of Tel Aviv it accommodates the Israeli military deep underground, where the pre-planning and the daily orders for the assaults on Gaza were made.

This supposed "mixed city" of Tel-Aviv/Yafo (even the name Jaffa is not used) has only 4.2% Palestinian residents, compared with the 20% of Israel's wider population – hardly an indication of the city's vaunted "diversity". In fact, as the author and architect Sharon Rotbard has pointed out, Jaffa existed before 1909 as mainly Arab, but in fact a mixed city, with many Palestinian Jews in suburbs established in 1887 and 1905. The new Tel Aviv was established by white European Jews, and thus, as Gabriel Ash says the centennial "is legitimising colonialism through the commemoration of the arrival of white Europeans to the orient".

The American historian VG Smith comments on Tel Aviv's Bauhaus architecture:

The myth of Tel Aviv as 'the White City' rests on the importation of style characteristics from European Modernism into Israel ... and can be understood as a vocabulary of forms or as a social movement to achieve a better life through architecture. To mimic International Style characteristics is as false as the nation's imitation of a modern state.

As an open letter put it last month, protesting at Toronto International Film Festival's decision to spotlight Tel Aviv:

Looking at modern, sophisticated Tel Aviv without also considering the city's past and the realities of Israeli occupation of the West Bank and the Gaza strip, would be like rhapsodising about the beauty and elegant lifestyles in white-only Cape Town or Johannesburg during apartheid without acknowledging the corresponding black townships of Khayelitsha and Soweto.

Gaza -January 2009

El Ad head admits City of David endangers Arab homes

By Akiva Eldar

Haaretz 5 October 2009

A video tape made during a guided tour of the archaeological excavations at Silwan (the City of David) near Jerusalem's Old City walls reveals how Elad, the association that runs the dig, works together with the Israel Antiquities Authority, the Israel Nature and Parks Authority and the Jerusalem municipality to dig under the homes of Arab residents.

In the tape, made a year ago, the founding head of Elad, David Be'eri, says: "At a certain point we came to court. The judge approached me and said, 'you're digging under their houses.' I said 'I'm digging under their houses? King David dug under their houses. I'm just cleaning.' He said to me, 'Clean as much as possible.' Since then, we're just cleaning; we're not digging."

Be'eri goes on to describe an excavation method in which "we built from the top down" and "everything's standing in the air" [due to the removal of fill]. "Then [the engineer] says, you have to shut the whole thing [because of danger of collapse]. I tell him, 'are you crazy?'"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t4OzNc9Hz_E&feature=related

In February a pit appeared on the steps connecting the upper part of the village to the lower sections. Three months later, the plaza, beneath which Elad is conducting its intensive excavations, began to collapse. A tour participant told Haaretz that she also heard Be'eri say he usually leaves a narrow entrance to a dig, and invites inspectors to crawl in. He said most of them make do with a look from the outside. As for construction of the visitors' center, Be'eri was also recorded as saying: "You dig and you dig ... and one day ... we found a rounded corner. We said this is a pool ... there's an 18-meter-high mountain here, above it are Arab houses. And I want to get to the bottom of the mountain, to the pool, to find it. How can I get there? We started to dig carefully, and support ourselves with metal struts that hold up the mountain and the houses. We found ourselves with five kilometers of welded iron inside. It's crazy. The cost of iron went up because of us." "We bought two rooms, this one and the one beneath ... and I started to build the visitors' center," Be'eri also said. "What can be done with two rooms? Nothing. So ... we broke the wall into the mountain ... All this space was a mountain filled with earth ... the Israel Antiquities Authority came and I told them, 'we're renovating...' At night I would move the terrace. They [the Antiquities Authority] would come in the morning and say, "Hey, it didn't look like this." The Israel Nature and Parks Authority has authorized Elad to run the site, encompassing some of the most extensive excavations in Israel in recent years. At the beginning of the 1990s, a Justice Ministry probe discovered that one of the buildings handed over to Elad, the Spring House, administered by the Custodian of Abandoned Properties, had been rented to Elad for NIS 23.73 per month. Elad also paid 3,000 Dinars to the Palestinian who lived there, to get him to leave. Two weeks ago, the High Court of Justice rejected two petitions by Silwan residents against all the bodies involved in excavations under their homes. In her ruling, Justice Edna Arbel cited the public interest in revealing thousands of years of Jerusalem's history. However, Arbel also said: "The importance of studying the past does not cancel out the interests of the present. It cannot preempt the right of the residents to live securely and cannot overcome the rule of law." The Israel Antiquities Authority did not respond to this report by press time. Elad responded that due to the lateness of the request for a response (in the early hours of Sunday afternoon) it was unable to respond. Related articles: Settlers marketing East Jerusalem homes for 22 Jewish families Israel authorizes building in another East Jerusalem neighborhood Plans for largest East Jerusalem settlement filed for approval