Israel Is Recreating the Nakba, Without Putting Palestinians on Trucks

https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium-israel-is-recreating-the-nakba-without-putting-people-on-trucks-1.9569024

by Ilana Hammerman      25 February 2021        Haaretz

Olive trees uprooted by Israeli soldiers at the West Bank Palestinian village of Deir Balut.Credit: Tomer Appelbaum

They’re closing in from all sides: the Jewish settlements on the Arab towns. Ariel, Revava, Kiryat Netafim, Barkan, Bruchin, Alei Zahav, Leshem, Yakir, Peduel, and Beit Arieh are spreading, approaching, and suffocating with fences and roads sown with roadblocks the city of Salfit and the towns of Kifl Haris, Haris, Brukin, Kfar al-Dik, Deir Balut and Deir Istiya. The vast municipal areas of the Jewish settlements, which were intended for their expansion, touch the Arab towns’ orchards and reach their houses. Some let their sewage flow into the villages, some have taken over springs and residents’ reservoirs and turned them into wading pools. Some sic their teenagers on farmers, to cut down and uproot their trees, to threaten, intimidate and destroy.

Israeli soldiers are aggressively doing the same. Bulldozers escorted by soldiers recently uprooted thousands of olive trees in Deir Balut and hundreds in Haris, and eviction orders are pending. One is for a resident of Kafr Hairs who owns a grove, who I met a few days ago accompanied by three other Jewish Israelis, one man and two women, activists from the Israeli group “dharma socially engaged.” 

This is the duplicitous way of the present Nakba: there is no need to put people on trucks or expel refugees in convoys

It isn’t only God in the details, the devil’s there too. The document was not served to the grove’s owner. It had been filled out ahead of time in “the absence of the owner” (a uniform format distributed to Palestinians for years, in thousands of copies), for posting “in three copies, at three conspicuous points”; and this detail had already been written in by hand, because some forms are crammed under a rock in the field or placed on it, and some are taped to a wall, and the inspector is required to describe this to a certain extent. The inspector sent to the grove of the Kafr Haris resident wrote out the form messily, hastily, maybe fearing the owner would suddenly pop up and he would find himself facing a person.

- Advertisment -

The top of the form names, in Hebrew and Arabic, the authorities tasked with evicting the Haris resident from his land. A pile of authorities: “Israel Defense Forces, The Civil Administration for the Judea and Samaria Region, the Commissioner for Government Property, the Central Unit for Oversight.” All operate according to orders and laws and the provisions of laws, which are even listed in the form for the information of the person slated for eviction: “In my authority according to the Order on Government Property (Judea and Samaria) (Number 59) 5727 – 1967, and according to Article 2 of the Order on the Matter of Appointments and Responsibilities according to the Law on the Protection of Land and Government Property (Judea and Samaria Number 1006) 5742 – 1982, I hereby state that you are illegally holding the land described herewith.”

Here is the description of the place where the land is (in handwriting): “Northeast of Kiryat Netafim on the land of Kafr Haris” (Like this!). The land itself, now called “the land and the trespass” (Like this! The Israeli army and its administrative arms are defending the land of Kafr Haris from trespassing village residents): “Olive trees in barrels, about 120, about 6.5 dunams” (1.625 acres). Appended to the document is an aerial photograph showing Kiryat Netafim and next to it a plot surrounded by a green line: This is the “trespass” area, according to the key at the bottom of the photograph. And now, Haris resident, you are required to “remove your hand from it and return to the land to its prior state within 45 days from the delivery of this order,” otherwise, “the responsible authority will act to carry out the eviction and will be empowered to charge you for the costs of the eviction.”

What is this Kiryat Netafim, because of which the small grove is slated to be uprooted because it touches the metal fencing and barbed wire of its expansions? A true place of beauty – read, believe and come: “Kiryat Netafim is a religious community in Samaria. The older and established community numbers about 200 families that enjoy a rich and lively community life. The young neighborhood being constructed in the community is the first significant expansion and is planned to attract young families seeking to improve and upgrade their standard of living and enjoy quality of life and a modern style of housing, in stylish and well-equipped apartments that offer residents a rich and pampered residential experience facing the beautiful landscape of Samaria” – says the developer.

This ad comes with a map showing that in this lovely vision, there is not even a single Arab community, just a very large number of Jewish communities.

• The Nakba - perpetuating a lie
• Palestinians uncover history of the Nakba, even as Israel cuts them off from their sources
• Burying the Nakba: How Israel systematically hides evidence of 1948 expulsion of Arabs

This is how the Nakba is being recreated in the West Bank, and not just there. From the southern Hebron Hills, Jordan Valley, Hebron, Bethlehem, Tul Karm through to Jenin; From Susya, Mevo’ot Yeriho, Efrat and Betar Ilit, Ariel and to Karnei Shomron, Hinanit and Shaked: Freedom, development and rule for the Jews only. This is the duplicitous way of the present Nakba: there is no need to put people on trucks or expel refugees in convoys. Aerial photographs of the authority called “the Civil Administration” already shows its presence well. The lands expropriated from non-Jewish presence are clearly marked on it; and on the ground, it advances in large steps toward ripping apart of the fabric of the life of millions of the Palestinian Arabs living here for generations.

Olive trees uprooted by Israeli soldiers at the West Bank Palestinian village of Deir Balut.Credit: Tomer Appelbaum

Evil from a beloved country

Once they were farmers. Today they are construction workers and renovators in the settlements and cities of Israel, and work in Israeli Jewish industrial factories built on their lands (or on public lands that were supposed to serve their needs which Israel turned into “state land” for Jews only). This is conditional on possessing work permits, money to buy them from middlemen and the strength to leave their homes for the checkpoints before the break of dawn and return home after dark.

Once they could have built homes on their land for their growing families. Today the built-up area of their communities is marked on maps precisely on the border of the last houses their forefathers built on them. This is the “Pale of Settlement” the State of Israel has allocated them.

The lands around these villages in Area C are mostly “state lands,” “surveyed lands,” “jurisdiction areas” of a regional council, or “municipal land” belonging to Jewish settlements, “military fire zones,” or “nature reserves.” All of these send out long tentacles, excrescences and pointed wedges meant to separate Palestinian communities, in which Arabs are not permitted to build, sow or plant. In some areas they can’t even set foot.

Visiting these locations together with their residents, looking at the uprooted and mutilated olive groves from a hilltop, watching the area become Jewish so arrogantly, quickly and efficiently, under the protection, active and violent intervention of the army and its soldiers, makes one want to disbelieve. To know you are a citizen of a military power that has been fighting these civilians all these years – that’s the only possible definition of what’s been happening – and to return home again and again, realizing how powerless you are, you and the Israelis who come to these places to see, accompany, extend a hand; helpless because they are only a handful in their society; to internalize this crazy reality which has become increasingly entrenched over the decades- one wants not to believe that such evil comes from a country in which there are still many things and people you love, the country with the landscape of your youth and mature years, with Hebrew as your art.

Over decades, we have reached the situation in which extremist, thuggish right-wing movements are fully legitimate in the Knesset and school system; the director of the B’Tselem human rights group cannot be invited to speak to pupils unless “balanced” by someone from those other movements, as though there really are two legitimate camps with legitimate values; we have reached the situation that election campaigns ignore this and Meretz’ leader says he’s willing to sit in a coalition led by Gideon Sa’ar, one of the main proponents of the Jewish nation-state ruling over the whole Land of Israel; we have reached the situation in which Israeli society has only a handful of people truly opposing – by their presence, with their bodies – the crimes committed by the army in which the sons and daughters of most members of this society serve.

We can only hope that the Israelis who know the scope of the disaster and are fearful for our fate here rise soon, and coalesce into a group that calls, from within Israeli society, on citizens, artists and human rights activists in Western countries, to act in their own countries for a change in discourse and policy regarding Israel’s path, for our sake, Jews and Palestinians, who together stand at the brink of an abyss, not only a moral one but a physical one as well; thousands who will cry out in a clear voice, which doubtlessly will be heard, to the international court in The Hague, to commence its investigations quickly.

There are judges in Jerusalem, AND they are the ones who have sanctioned and continue to sanction all of this.

Making such a call is not pure antisemitism, as claimed by Benjamin Netanyahu – antisemitism is a term Israel’s leaders have managed to completely twist – it is pure Judaism, and even more so, it is humanism and political wisdom that can see into the future.

***************************************************************************************